Anyone can edit this page!
Although this is HaydenBobMutthew's user page, other users are encouraged to edit it and its subpages.
Note: This is my suggestion, don't take it too serious, as said by tryashtar, the recipes are designed for proper gameplay reasons,[1] but you can feel free to add any unintuitive crafting recipe.
Note: This is my suggestion, don't take it too serious, as said by tryashtar, the recipes are designed for proper gameplay reasons,[1] but you can feel free to add any unintuitive crafting recipe.
These lists note the crafting recipes that should probably be changed, with the reason provided.
Most common reasons:
- Not proportional
- It is not specific enough
- Inconsistency between editions
- Can be simplified
- Not realistic
Blocks
| Output | Current | Suggested | Reason | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planks | A bit more realistic, assuming the planks is hollow. | |||
| Wood | Not proportional.[2] | |||
| Stairs | Not proportional, also, the recipe don't reflect the 2-step nature of the stairs. | |||
| Crafting Table | The crafting table is made with oak and not proportional. | |||
| Furnace | Not proportional. | |||
| Dispenser | Not proportional. | |||
| Dropper | Not proportional. | |||
| Blast Furnace | Not proportional. | |||
| Smoker | Not proportional. | |||
| Fletching Table | The fletching table is made with birch and not proportional. | |||
| Smithing Table | The smithing table is seemingly made with dark oak and not proportional. | |||
| Cartography Table | The cartography table is made with dark oak and not proportional. | |||
| Chest | Not proportional. | |||
| Barrel | Java Edition: Bedrock Edition: |
The barrel is made with spruce and not proportional. | ||
| Stonecutter | Not proportional. | |||
| Campfire | Not proportional. | |||
| Colored Wool | Java Edition: Bedrock Edition: |
Inconsistent to terracotta and glass dyeing. Also, Bedrock Edition dyeing is a flaw in logic, since color will mix, but the recipe is not, a paradox. | ||
| Carpet | Not proportional. | |||
| Bed | Not proportional and the base is made of oak. | |||
| Colored Bed | Bedrock Edition dyeing is a flaw in logic, since color will mix, but the recipe is not, a paradox. | |||
| Wooden Trapdoor | Not proportional. | |||
| Composter | Java Edition: Bedrock Edition: |
Not proportional. | ||
| Piston | Not proportional and the arm is made of oak. | |||
| Redstone Repeater | Not proportional and the base of redstone repeater is made of smooth stone, not stone. | |||
| Redstone Comparator | Not proportional and the base of redstone comparator is made of smooth stone, not stone. | |||
| Redstone Lamp | Not proportional. | |||
| Daylight Detector | Not proportional and more realistic, in parity with clock. | |||
| Hopper | Not proportional and the chest is unnecessary. | |||
| Observer | Not proportional. | |||
| Button | Not proportional. | |||
| Note Block | Not proportional. | |||
| Jukebox | Not proportional. | |||
| TNT | Not proportional, also sand and red sand can be both used. | |||
| Brewing Stand | Not proportional. | |||
| Glowstone | Consistency to redstone block. | |||
| Beacon | Not proportional. | |||
| Loom | Not proportional. | |||
| Lectern | The lectern is made with oak and not proportional. | |||
| Rail | Not proportional. | |||
| Glass Pane | Not proportional. | |||
| Diorite | Inconsistent to Granite. | |||
| Wood Door | Not proportional. | |||
| Iron Door | Not proportional. | |||
| Ender Chest | Not proportional. | |||
| Snow | Not proportional. | |||
| Snow Block | class="wikitable " data-description="Crafting recipes" | Ingredients | Crafting recipe | |
| Snowball |
|As a full snow (snow with 8 layers) drops 8 snowball, so the recipe. |}
Items
| Output | Current | Suggested | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stick | Not proportional. | ||
| Clock | Clock in real-life have quartz to make timekeeping accurate and not proportional. | ||
| Bowl | Not proportional. | ||
| Glowstone | Consistency to redstone dust. | ||
| Cake | There is a big berry on the top of the cake.[3] | ||
| Bucket | Resolve crafting conflict with hopper. | ||
| Item Frame | Not proportional. |