This page serves to begin a discussion which will decide whether or not the English Minecraft Wiki will fork from Fandom, and if so, where it should fork to.
It is requested that all editors discuss and give opinions on this matter, as it is a drastic change for the Minecraft Wiki and will affect all editors and readers in some way or another.
Before discussing
Before you give your comment(s), please read the following two pages to get important background information and be able to form an informed opinion:
- Community portal#Move to a different wiki host? - the first message in this community portal topic details the reasons behind why forking the wiki is being considered
- Host comparison page - this page details the many differences between the four hosting options available, it is essential to read if you wish to decide where you think the Minecraft Wiki should fork to
In the #Discussion section below, please rank each host option from most preferred (1) to least preferred (4) and give your reasoning in the format shown below:
* {{subst:Vote|Rank #1|Rank #2|Rank #3|Rank #4}} – <reasoning> ~~~~
Both the votes and the arguments given will be factored into the final decision. The vote you give should be representative of your own opinion on the matter, and not the general opinion of an entire language wiki.
For additional comments that do not directly express a vote, such as clarification questions, please use the #Additional comments section.
This discussion will be closed two weeks from the discussion's start date, on July 17, 2023. If the discussion still has active participants near the end of these two weeks, the duration of the discussion will be extended by one week, closing on July 24, 2023 instead.
Discussion
This is the main "voting" section.
- ABXY Bulba Fandom wiki.gg - I Support an eventual move. No notifications in wiki.gg is an immediate blocker. Anon editing will help with wiki interaction. MetalManiacMc, French Minecraft Wiki Administrator 18:34, 3 July 2023 (UTC)
- wiki.gg ABXY Fandom Bulba - For me, the lack of notifs isn't that much of deal. Most of the messages I had received with Echo were useless, however I agree some may see it from a different POV. Bulba has more ads than Fandom. I mean, one of the biggest responses from the community was how Fandom has so many ads and I cannot imagine that we would come and say "Well, have even more ads". Additionally, we won't get anon editing and we will also take legal responsibility for actions we (as a community will do). ABXY does not have cookie notice, which is recipe for disaster. Once we would raise awareness, we would be in some legal trouble. And also lacks widgets extension, which would require even more time to perform the fork. TreeIsLife (talk) 18:47, 3 July 2023 (UTC)
- Fandom N/A N/A N/A – I do not support forking simply because having two similar wikis on different platforms is disastrous, especially when the most known and visible one is out of date (Fandom if we move). For most non EN wikis the editor base is really small and one-time editors will likely edit the Fandom one. And it would bring so much work and so many issues that I don't find it worth it. Fusion thermonucleaire (talk) 19:02, 3 July 2023 (UTC)
Additional comments
This section is for additional discussion separate from the main vote.