User talk:BDJP007301

Regarding the Bedrock Edition page
First of all, sorry for the exclamation point on my recent edit-revert... I didn't mean to sound like I was shouting or anything. Sorry if it was interpreted that way.

Apple TV shouldn't be listed under "Upcoming" because it is already has "Bedrock". It doesn't have 1.2, but it does have Bedrock. The Bedrock name was already being used for the codebase during 1.1 development, and Bedrock is supposed to be a retroactively-applied name just like Legacy Console Edition & Java Edition. So 1.1 is Bedrock, 0.16 is Bedrock, even 0.1.0 is technically Bedrock, even though it wasn't called that at the time. Putting Apple TV under "Upcoming" doesn't make sense to me... it implies that Apple TV is not running Bedrock, and that Bedrock is a "new" edition that just got released or something, which isn't the case.

HelenAngel said the following here: https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Minecraft_Wiki_talk:Projects/Renaming#Project.27s_next_step

"Also, for everything but Xbox (& Switch later), there wasn't a relaunch- the edition names just got dropped."

So I think it's safe to say that Apple TV is running Bedrock Edition. Yes, it doesn't say "Bedrock Edition" in the game, but neither do any of the other versions of Bedrock Edition. Bedrock Edition isn't really an official title anyway... it's just a convenient term based off of the name of the codebase. The actual title is simply "Minecraft", but for the sake of treating codebases equally and not being too confusing, the term Bedrock Edition is being used on the wiki. And just like how all Console Edition versions are now called Legacy Console Edition versions, the same applies here. Do you agree?

Also, I understand wanting to make the platform list simpler, and that was probably a good move. There is a bit of a problem, though, in that Windows 10 Mobile is no longer being listed separately from Windows 10. The reason I did the more verbose list in the first place was because Windows 10 Mobile uses the same icon as Windows 10 and it was confusing to have 2 identical icons shown next to each other. I guess an icon could be made that uses the Windows 10 logo but with the word "Mobile" in Segoe font beside it... that's probably what I'll do. SuperGeniusZeb (talk) 02:18, 4 October 2017 (UTC)

Okay, I made a Win10 Mobile logo and added it to the list, so that solves that problem. SuperGeniusZeb (talk) 16:27, 4 October 2017 (UTC)